The U.S. Surgeon General, Dr. Vivek Murthy, has called for warning labels to be placed on social media platforms, akin to those required on tobacco and alcohol products. This suggestion was made in a recent opinion piece published in The New York Times, where he appealed to Congress to adopt this measure.
The call for such warning labels follows the U.S. Surgeon General’s advisory published in 2023 on Social Media and Youth Mental Health, which stated that social media may pose risks to the mental health of young users, but insufficient evidence exists to conclude it is safe for children and adolescents.
Dr. Myles McNutt, an Associate Professor of Communication and Theatre Arts at Old Dominion University, further discusses this topic in a digital news segment. According to McNutt, while social media platforms can have negative effects on mental health, particularly for young people, their primary goal is to increase engagement and generate revenue.
The complexity of addressing the risks and rewards of social media was also emphasized by McNutt, as there is no blanket consensus among experts on the best solutions due to the varied nature of social media platforms. McNutt also pointed out that the impacts of social media are intricate, with some depending on users’ choices and platform-specific aspects.
Warning labels could be seen as a way for parents to be aware of potential risks, yet their efficacy in solving the issue remains questionable for media scholars, as the understanding of the science and effects of social media varies among experts. Furthermore, McNutt noted that creating a concise and informative warning label would be challenging because it might not capture all the intricacies involved with social media and its effects on mental health.
One concern raised is that warning labels could shift responsibility for user protection away from the social media platforms and towards the users themselves. Social media, despite its documented downsides, can also function as a tool for connecting people, promoting uplifting content, and teaching new skills.
As discussions concerning the impact of social media on children continue, McNutt offers general advice to users. He suggests that individuals who find little joy or benefit from a social media platform should consider leaving it. The complete digital news segment offers further insights from McNutt on this topic.